Sunday, November 15

{mascara experiment}

Which is the $6 Maybelline Volum Express Mascara and which is the $30 YSL Singulier Mascara?? Both have one coat only.



  • ease of application: The YSL was much smoother. It just glides on, while the Maybelline catches and clumps and requires more strokes to smooth out the clumps.
  • Neither mascara flaked at all which was impressive.
  • ease of removal: Both mascaras remove easily with makeup remover.

18 comments:

Pamela said...

First of all-your lashes are so long!!!!

I can barely tell the difference between them, which is great!
I'm going to guess that the top pic is Maybelline and botton is YSL. Just a guess though, as they both look equally as good.

Debra said...

he top is the YSL

Lula Mae said...

They actually both look good. My guess is the bottom is YSL?

In this wonderful life... said...

I bet the top is Maybelline and the bottom is YSL!?

Randall @ Happy For This Moment said...

The top one looks thicker but the bottom one "cleaner" if that makes sense. I love my Cover Girl so I'll always root for the drugstore brand!

Laura Trevey said...

great little experiment !!

The 5 Bickies said...

I think the top if Maybelline and the bottom is YSL. Very curious to know the answer and which you will use on a daily basis.

Mrs. K said...

ok yeah you so don't need latisse! :) top is maybelline...clumpy...bottom is YSL...nice!

Puttin' On The GRITS said...

Whichever is which...I think I prefer the top! I like more "noticeable" lashes and that mascara makes them look thicker.

Cary said...

Don't know which one is which but the bottom looks gorgeous so wear that one every single day! FYI-your lashes are amazing!!! Xoxo

Ann said...

Okay, WOW. You're like an anti-Latisse advertisement. You have totally awesome lashes.

'Fess up. ;)

Mommy, Esq. said...

the bottom is ySL... right?

short southern momma said...

you have the most beautiful eyes girl! hope your having a great day! xoxo

yogagirl said...

#1 is Maybelline and so #2 is YSL!

Southern Belle said...

I think #2 is YSL.

Jaina said...

My guess is the bottom is the YSL. They both look great on you though :)

monogramgirl said...

I love the bottom mascara!

k e r r y said...

You don't have a single wrinkle!!