Surprisingly very very comfortable! Unfortunately, the toe is shaped into a point, so there was way too much room in front of my toes. With open sandals it is nice when the toe is more rounded to the natural shape of the foot. Sadly these will be going back. They are overpriced at $198, but all J Crew shoes with their leather-upper/manmade sole construction are overpriced in my opinion. This is the Tan Rose color which is a neutral light beige color that will darken over time due to the vachetta leather. It looks slightly darker on the models in the catalog.
I had high hopes for these and they let me down. The entire toe/foot area is SO SKINNY that this is as far as I could shove my foot (and I am squeezing my foot forward in this picture) into the sandal. If your foot is as flat as cardboard then these will fit you fine! Way too much room in front of the toes again. Man made sole for $150. On the positive side--I love the color of the leather!
And on an unrelated note,
Fit is loose--you must go down a size in these unless you want that loose saggy boyfriend look. They arrive already cuffed and the cuff unrolls to just below the ankle on me. These are the cutest distressed jeans I've seen yet. They are not overly distressed, so when the ripped-up trend is over these will still be cute!